Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Kevin Pieters » Tue, 08 Oct 1996 04:00:00


Quote:
> > Whatever Cronje's done against other opposition, he's never done
> > much against England.  Though it's feasible he may be weak against
> > one opponent while excellent against the rest.

Let's see....

    ODIs vs England 95/96:
        24 off 45 balls
        19 off 18 balls
        7 off 10 balls    (2 wickets for 57)
        47 off 46 balls
        78 off 133 balls
        13 off 28 balls
        60 of 78 balls
Giving him an average of 35, plus 3 catches and 4 wickets.  In the England side
only Stewart and Thorpe had a better average (43 and 46) with the next best
Englishmen at 28.4.
And in the World Cup against England:
        15 of 31 balls

Nothing much wrong there for ODI play.  Plus he captained SA to beat England 7 to
1 in 1995/6.  Call that poor?  Kicking ***is what I call it.  Hansie is a Captain first,
and a player second, that's why he is good, and that's what England and Pakistan
needs (the only other good Captain I think IMHO is Ranatunga)

He was runout, b by Cork, b by de Freitas, b by Illingworth, b White twice, b Martin.

That's all.
--
Kevin

 
 
 

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Sailesh Krishnamurth » Tue, 08 Oct 1996 04:00:00

    >> > Whatever Cronje's done against other opposition, he's
    >> never done > much against England.  Though it's feasible
    >> he may be weak against > one opponent while excellent
    >> against the rest.

<snip Cronje's ODI record against England>

    Kevin> Nothing much wrong there for ODI play.  Plus he
    Kevin> captained SA to beat England 7 to 1 in 1995/6.  Call
    Kevin> that poor?  Kicking ***is what I call it.  Hansie is

Not if the original poster was talking about tests:

Here is Cronje's record:
(From HowzStat:
http://SportToday.org/:8080/home/chris/cricket.dir/wwwpage...)

                 T    I   NO      R     AVG   50  100    HS     Ct   St
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Australia        6   10    0    343   34.30    1    1  122       1    0
England          8   12    1    203   18.45    0    0   48       2    0
India            3    6    1    207   41.40    0    1  135       0    0
New Zealand      4    7    1    369   61.50    1    2  112       3    0
Pakistan         1    2    0     89   44.50    0    0   48       0    0
Sri Lanka        3    5    1    237   59.25    1    1  122       3    0
West Indies      1    2    0      7    3.50    0    0    5       0    0
Zimbabwe         1    2    1     61   61.00    1    0   56*      1    0

Last 10 Tests   10   15    2    550   42.30    1    2  112       3    0
Home            15   24    2    826   37.54    1    3  135       3    0
Away            12   22    3    690   36.31    3    2  122       7    0
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOTAL           27   46    5   1516   36.97    4    5  135      10    0
As Captain      13   20    2    661   36.72    2    2   112      4    0

Definitely Cronje's record against England is poor.

    Kevin> a Captain first, and a player second, that's why he is
    Kevin> good,

This is true .. observe that although he has played half his
tests as captain, his overall record as captain and otherwise is
almost identical. Shows remarkable consistency.

Still I won't put Hansie as the "Best Batsman in the World"
.. not by a long shot. (However, notice that his performance in
his Last 10 Tests has been pretty good)

--
Cheers
Sailesh
http://SportToday.org/

 
 
 

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Nicholas M Bennet » Sat, 19 Oct 1996 04:00:00

Listen Mate, he's good but nothing like Lara, Tendulkar, de Silva or even
ALec Stewart of England. Get real, he's a top captain and leader, but
world-class he'll never be.
                                Nick M Bennett


 
 
 

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Janine Erasm » Tue, 22 Oct 1996 04:00:00



Quote:
>Listen Mate, he's good but nothing like Lara, Tendulkar, de Silva or even
>ALec Stewart of England. Get real, he's a top captain and leader, but
>world-class he'll never be.
>                            Nick M Bennett


Oooh, I have to agree on this. Sadly. Cronje is great! I am a big fan of his
captaincy - maybe he's world class in that?  Despite being firmly
anti-sticker, I have even thought about getting a 'I love Hansie' one. :)
Pity about the batting, though.  I often think he can either be a captain or a
batsman, but not both.  Which doesn't stop me from being rooted to my chair
when he bats, only to get coffee some fif*** runs later because he is heading
for the dressing room again...
Now Kirsten, on the other hand, might just turn out to be someone we can spend
a whole day watching.  
 
 
 

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Simon Pleasan » Wed, 30 Oct 1996 04:00:00

Quote:



>>Listen Mate, he's good but nothing like Lara, Tendulkar, de Silva or even
>>ALec Stewart of England. Get real, he's a top captain and leader, but
>>world-class he'll never be.

>Oooh, I have to agree on this. Sadly. Cronje is great! I am a big fan of his
>captaincy - maybe he's world class in that?  Despite being firmly
>anti-sticker, I have even thought about getting a 'I love Hansie' one. :)
>Pity about the batting, though.  I often think he can either be a captain or a
>batsman, but not both.  Which doesn't stop me from being rooted to my chair
>when he bats, only to get coffee some fif*** runs later because he is heading
>for the dressing room again...

And I have to agree too.  He is not even the best of South Africa's
line up, let alone the world's!  I also have to question the first of
the two posters quoted - I am a huge fan of Alec Stewart, my favourite
England player, but I'm not sure that he deserves a mention along with
the others in that list, either.  Maybe he would have been there if
they had given him a batting number years ago and left him there,
rather than shunt him up and down the order and make him keep and then
change their minds and then drop him and then make him vice captain
and then change their minds again!

Quote:
>Now Kirsten, on the other hand, might just turn out to be someone we can spend
>a whole day watching.  

When England were playing South Africa I kept my eye on Kirsten and
Cullinan.  If we dealt with them I felt we were in with a chance,
assuming the match didn't get rained off as most of them seemed to.

Simon

--

Homepage http://SportToday.org/~dreampages/index.htm
"Lawyers are like atom bombs..." (Larry The Liquidator)

 
 
 

Why Hansie Cronje is the best Batsman in the world!

Post by Simon Anderso » Tue, 05 Nov 1996 04:00:00

Quote:




> >>Listen Mate, he's good but nothing like Lara, Tendulkar, de Silva or even
> >>ALec Stewart of England. Get real, he's a top captain and leader, but
> >>world-class he'll never be.

> >Oooh, I have to agree on this. Sadly. Cronje is great! I am a big fan of his
> >captaincy - maybe he's world class in that?

Absolutely I think Hansie is one of the best thinking captains in world
cricket, and the best of the current crop. I would rate him alongside
Allan Border (although his record has yet to compare to Border's though)
as a captain who can outhink batsmen.

Bob Woolmer must be given a lot of credit here for the help he has given
Hansie. (Is there any doubt that Bob is the world's best coach?)
.

Simon.