"Latest affair reflects badly on Australia" says The Australian

"Latest affair reflects badly on Australia" says The Australian

Post by Irfa » Fri, 05 Nov 1999 04:00:00


Understatement of the year from the The Australian :-)

Latest affair reflects badly on Australia
Comment by MIKE COWARD

5nov99

WHAT is it about Pakistan which brings out the worst in us? The
furore surrounding Shoaib Akhtar should embarrass Australia.

Little wonder there are good people throughout the sub-continent
who consider Australia to be xenophobic.

Certainly the apparent branding of Shoaib, one of the game's very
few international headliners, bespeaks of cultural elitism.

Already one Australian cricketer has apologised to Shoaib for the hurt
and embarrassment he has been caused and others are expected to
follow suit.

The Australian Cricket Board says it is embarrassed the report about
Shoaib's bowling action was leaked.

And so it should be, for someone in Perth has acted in the most
mischievous manner and done Australian cricket a great disservice.

Only time will tell how much harm has been done.

But it doesn't auger well when you start a season of such potential
with an empty feeling in the pit of your gut.

We should be salivating at the prospect of Shoaib, Wasim Akram,
Saqlain Mushtaq, Mushtaq Ahmed, Saeed Anwar, Ijaz Ahmed and
Yousuf Youhana strutting their stuff before turning our attention to
peerless Sachin Tendulkar and his gifted Indian team-mates including
Rahul Dravid, Sourav Ganguly, Javagal Srinath and Anil Kumble.

But as so often happens when Pakistan are about, there is a
considerable distraction. Australians have distrusted Pakistani
cricketers since the very first Test in 1956, when it is said that
pebbles were surreptitiously pushed under the matting to give gifted
swing and seam bowler Fazal Mahmood an unfair advantage. Pakistan
won the match.

While it is true Pakistan have done little to help their cause and
credibility in recent years, as *** and match-fixing controversies
have raged, Pakistan skipper Wasim Akram and former captains Mark
Taylor and Aamir Sohail have at the same time worked to improve
relations.

On balance, these two teams get on pretty well and it is to be hoped
this latest upheaval does not undermine the considerable gains made
over the past four years.

Thankfully, Shoaib has Wasim as his guru. Wasim has been through it
all and then some and get provide perspective.

As distressing as the hurt to Shoaib was the admission by Wasim that
he was not surprised a malicious whispering campaign was launched
the moment his team reached these shores.

"Why, when some opposition team comes here, do they have a go at
them in such a way instead of praising the talent we have, of saying
he is the fastest bowler and will get some wickets instead of having a
go at him in a negative way?"

This is a reasonable question from one of the game's foremost players
and leaders and it provides something of an insight into the way the
rest of the world can view Australian cricket.

The leaking of the report on Shoaib by Ric Evans, the director of
umpiring in Western Australia, has changed the tenor and focus of
this series before a ball has been bowled.

A week ago everyone was preparing to look at Shoaib for all the right
reasons. Now they may well watch for all the wrong reasons.

This is a great pity and again places Australian cricket in a very poor
light.

 
 
 

"Latest affair reflects badly on Australia" says The Australian

Post by Moby Dic » Sat, 06 Nov 1999 04:00:00

I love that.. from the very people who published the damned thing in the
first place, we have an accusation levelled against everyone else.

Instead of an apology for printing, we get a high and mighty roasting from
the very people who are at fault.

Freedom of the press.. HA!

Self-indulgent BS of the press more like it.

Quote:

> Understatement of the year from the The Australian :-)

> Latest affair reflects badly on Australia
> Comment by MIKE COWARD

> 5nov99

> WHAT is it about Pakistan which brings out the worst in us? The
> furore surrounding Shoaib Akhtar should embarrass Australia.

> Little wonder there are good people throughout the sub-continent
> who consider Australia to be xenophobic.

> Certainly the apparent branding of Shoaib, one of the game's very
> few international headliners, bespeaks of cultural elitism.

> Already one Australian cricketer has apologised to Shoaib for the hurt
> and embarrassment he has been caused and others are expected to
> follow suit.

> The Australian Cricket Board says it is embarrassed the report about
> Shoaib's bowling action was leaked.

> And so it should be, for someone in Perth has acted in the most
> mischievous manner and done Australian cricket a great disservice.

> Only time will tell how much harm has been done.

> But it doesn't auger well when you start a season of such potential
> with an empty feeling in the pit of your gut.

> We should be salivating at the prospect of Shoaib, Wasim Akram,
> Saqlain Mushtaq, Mushtaq Ahmed, Saeed Anwar, Ijaz Ahmed and
> Yousuf Youhana strutting their stuff before turning our attention to
> peerless Sachin Tendulkar and his gifted Indian team-mates including
> Rahul Dravid, Sourav Ganguly, Javagal Srinath and Anil Kumble.

> But as so often happens when Pakistan are about, there is a
> considerable distraction. Australians have distrusted Pakistani
> cricketers since the very first Test in 1956, when it is said that
> pebbles were surreptitiously pushed under the matting to give gifted
> swing and seam bowler Fazal Mahmood an unfair advantage. Pakistan
> won the match.

> While it is true Pakistan have done little to help their cause and
> credibility in recent years, as *** and match-fixing controversies
> have raged, Pakistan skipper Wasim Akram and former captains Mark
> Taylor and Aamir Sohail have at the same time worked to improve
> relations.

> On balance, these two teams get on pretty well and it is to be hoped
> this latest upheaval does not undermine the considerable gains made
> over the past four years.

> Thankfully, Shoaib has Wasim as his guru. Wasim has been through it
> all and then some and get provide perspective.

> As distressing as the hurt to Shoaib was the admission by Wasim that
> he was not surprised a malicious whispering campaign was launched
> the moment his team reached these shores.

> "Why, when some opposition team comes here, do they have a go at
> them in such a way instead of praising the talent we have, of saying
> he is the fastest bowler and will get some wickets instead of having a
> go at him in a negative way?"

> This is a reasonable question from one of the game's foremost players
> and leaders and it provides something of an insight into the way the
> rest of the world can view Australian cricket.

> The leaking of the report on Shoaib by Ric Evans, the director of
> umpiring in Western Australia, has changed the tenor and focus of
> this series before a ball has been bowled.

> A week ago everyone was preparing to look at Shoaib for all the right
> reasons. Now they may well watch for all the wrong reasons.

> This is a great pity and again places Australian cricket in a very poor
> light.

Moby***.
The revolution is dead.  Long live the revolution.

 
 
 

"Latest affair reflects badly on Australia" says The Australian

Post by Mad Hami » Sat, 06 Nov 1999 04:01:00

Quote:

>Understatement of the year from the The Australian :-)

>Latest affair reflects badly on Australia
>Comment by MIKE COWARD

>5nov99

>WHAT is it about Pakistan which brings out the worst in us? The
>furore surrounding Shoaib Akhtar should embarrass Australia.

What furore has anyone _but_the_press_ been involved in.
The umpires didn't call him. Someone else thought that his action looked a bit
different and put together a video which they thought that the ACB could look at
if they wanted to examine his action.

This was not official and was not made public by anybody in an official
position.

Quote:

>Little wonder there are good people throughout the sub-continent
>who consider Australia to be xenophobic.

Yeah, somebody being concerned about unusual bowling actions clearly labels us
as xenophobic...

Quote:

>Certainly the apparent branding of Shoaib, one of the game's very
>few international headliners, bespeaks of cultural elitism.

The branding has come solely from the press. He hasn't been called, there hasn't
been an official report.

In any case Shoaib being a "headliner" should not matter. If any bowler's action
is legal then whether he's a debutant or an estableished campaigner he should be
fine, if his action is illegal then he should be called, irrespective of the
number of matches he's played.

Quote:

>Already one Australian cricketer has apologised to Shoaib for the hurt
>and embarrassment he has been caused and others are expected to
>follow suit.

And can they actually explain the rules of cricket?

Quote:

>The Australian Cricket Board says it is embarrassed the report about
>Shoaib's bowling action was leaked.

Gee, who published it?
Quote:

>And so it should be, for someone in Perth has acted in the most
>mischievous manner and done Australian cricket a great disservice.

Gee, who published it?

IT wasn't mentioned in "The Australian" was it?

Quote:
>Only time will tell how much harm has been done.

>But it doesn't auger well when you start a season of such potential
>with an empty feeling in the pit of your gut.

Forgot to bring your wallet and had to skip lunch did you?

Quote:

>We should be salivating at the prospect of Shoaib, Wasim Akram,
>Saqlain Mushtaq, Mushtaq Ahmed, Saeed Anwar, Ijaz Ahmed and
>Yousuf Youhana strutting their stuff before turning our attention to
>peerless Sachin Tendulkar and his gifted Indian team-mates including
>Rahul Dravid, Sourav Ganguly, Javagal Srinath and Anil Kumble.

I'm looking forwards to the summer. I don't know that I agree with some of his
predictions for the names of the summer.

Quote:

>But as so often happens when Pakistan are about, there is a
>considerable distraction. Australians have distrusted Pakistani
>cricketers since the very first Test in 1956, when it is said that
>pebbles were surreptitiously pushed under the matting to give gifted
>swing and seam bowler Fazal Mahmood an unfair advantage. Pakistan
>won the match.

a) First I've ever heard of that accusation.
b) I don't recall too much in the way of distrust of their cricketers amongst
players of the 70s and early 80s. They weren't always happy about the umpiring
but that's a different issue.

Quote:

>As distressing as the hurt to Shoaib was the admission by Wasim that
>he was not surprised a malicious whispering campaign was launched
>the moment his team reached these shores.

>"Why, when some opposition team comes here, do they have a go at
>them in such a way instead of praising the talent we have, of saying
>he is the fastest bowler

Maybe because fast does not equate to effective at test level?

Quote:
>and will get some wickets instead of having a go at him in a negative way?"

If somebody has doubts about his action then it's fair enough to investigate it.
Especially when somebody is delivering a cricket ball at 95-100mph...

That is a dangerous object and if he's doing it with an illegal action then he
shouldn't be playing.

I have absolutely no sympathy for any fast bowler who throws _Because_ they're
clearly getting a benefit from it in terms of pace _and_ causing an increased
risk of physical injury. That doesn't mean that I believe that Akhtar throws,
just that if _any_ quick bowler throws they have to correct the action or get
out of the game; as Olonga of Zimbabwe did.

Quote:

>This is a reasonable question from one of the game's foremost players
>and leaders and it provides something of an insight into the way the
>rest of the world can view Australian cricket.

It's hardly reasonable to accuse them of a whispering campaign when _1_ person
puts together a tape and sends it to the ACB...

Quote:

>The leaking of the report on Shoaib by Ric Evans, the director of
>umpiring in Western Australia, has changed the tenor and focus of
>this series before a ball has been bowled.

Who published it?

Quote:

>A week ago everyone was preparing to look at Shoaib for all the right
>reasons. Now they may well watch for all the wrong reasons.

We'll see. I want a look at his action and see if I can detect any straightening
of the elbow...

Quote:

>This is a great pity and again places Australian cricket in a very poor
>light.

Who published it?

****************************************************************************
The Politician's Slogan
'You can fool all of the people some of the time and some of the people all
of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time.
Fortunately only a simple majority is required.'
****************************************************************************

Mad Hamish

Hamish Laws