Shikhar Dhawan

Shikhar Dhawan

Post by Maxx » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 20:43:09


Is it just me or does he remind anyone else of Kambli?  Talented,
flamboyant, left handed etc.

Perhaps he can do what Kambli couldn't - make a flying start and
continue.

Nice article to get the juices flowing for the SA-IND series at the
end of the year:

http://www.cricket365.com/india/story/8611397/-Bring-it-on-Steyn-the-...

Should be a cracker

 
 
 

Shikhar Dhawan

Post by RSX » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 01:35:24


Quote:
> Is it just me or does he remind anyone else of Kambli? ?Talented,
> flamboyant, left handed etc.

> Perhaps he can do what Kambli couldn't - make a flying start and
> continue.

> Nice article to get the juices flowing for the SA-IND series at the
> end of the year:

> http://www.cricket365.com/india/story/8611397/-Bring-it-on-Steyn-the-...

> Should be a cracker

Nope. It will be one sided. If India plays well, one match may be a
draw.

 
 
 

Shikhar Dhawan

Post by D Ramapriy » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 10:45:16


Quote:
> Is it just me or does he remind anyone else of Kambli? ?Talented,
> flamboyant, left handed etc.

> Perhaps he can do what Kambli couldn't - make a flying start and
> continue.

Kambli played the last of his 17 Tests at an age when Dhawan hadn't
even made his debut. If there was someone like a Kirsten or Wright as
coach when he played, with a good bunch of selectors, he'd have - or
should have - played at least 50 Tests more. Any which way you dice
it, it's ghastly that someone with Kambli's record played as little as
he did. I don't buy any of the stories about his Ryder-like off-field
life and so-called weakness against short deliveries as the excuse to
finish him off in Tests.

Quote:
> Nice article to get the juices flowing for the SA-IND series at the
> end of the year:

> http://www.cricket365.com/india/story/8611397/-Bring-it-on-Steyn-the-...

> Should be a cracker

Don't know about RSA but Dhawan sure would feel at home in Oz because
his wife stays in Melbourne :)

Ramapriya

 
 
 

Shikhar Dhawan

Post by vijaykum.. » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 13:23:57


Quote:

> > Is it just me or does he remind anyone else of Kambli? ?Talented,
> > flamboyant, left handed etc.

> > Perhaps he can do what Kambli couldn't - make a flying start and
> > continue.

> Kambli played the last of his 17 Tests at an age when Dhawan hadn't
> even made his debut. If there was someone like a Kirsten or Wright as
> coach when he played, with a good bunch of selectors, he'd have - or
> should have - played at least 50 Tests more. Any which way you dice
> it, it's ghastly that someone with Kambli's record played as little as
> he did. I don't buy any of the stories about his Ryder-like off-field
> life and so-called weakness against short deliveries as the excuse to
> finish him off in Tests.

> > Nice article to get the juices flowing for the SA-IND series at the
> > end of the year:

> >http://SportToday.org/

> > Should be a cracker

> Don't know about RSA but Dhawan sure would feel at home in Oz because
> his wife stays in Melbourne :)

> Ramapriya

I watched Kambli bat at the ***hede in 94/5 v WI. With Dravid,
Laxman and even Ganguly (in addition to the already established
Azhar, Sachin and Manjrekar) in contention for MO spots, there is
no way he would have lasted another 50 tests. His technique was
too suspect - and his attitude probably made sure that he never
got around to working on it and fixing it. Ganguly had problems with
technique as well, but he was determined enough to overcome it
and have a decent Test career (I believe SCG does not get enough
credit for his sheer determination and grit - most people see only
the flamboyant and lazy prince of Calcutta in him).

Vijay

 
 
 

Shikhar Dhawan

Post by D Ramapriy » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 14:19:02



Quote:

> I watched Kambli bat at the ***hede in 94/5 v WI. With Dravid,
> Laxman and even Ganguly (in addition to the already established
> Azhar, Sachin and Manjrekar) in contention for MO spots, there is
> no way he would have lasted another 50 tests. His technique was
> too suspect - and his attitude

You mean the attitude that got him 10k FC runs at 60 and the
perseverence of going on till 2005, well after anyone in his shoes
would've given up hope of an international recall?

He wasn't even 24 when he played the last of his 17 Tests. He got to a
thousand Test runs in 14 innings and his Test career aggregate stands
at 1,084 runs. If you think that that's a long enough rope ere
condemnation and an appropriate age to give up on a guy with that sort
of record, I've little else to add. RSD, VVSL and SCG all began their
Test careers circa the age when Kambli was dropped for good. They had
their little chinks but got better by ironing them out. There's no
saying that Kambli too would have but he wasn't even given a half-
decent chance other than occasionally in ODIs, which anyway is a very
different cuppa.

Ramapriya