Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Sanja » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 03:15:52


Gambhir is an over rated player with faulty technique to open for India both
in ODs and tests. Gambhir is a tiger against minnows bangladesh and
zimbabwe.

Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance against
Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by ampar.. » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 03:30:52

Quote:

> Gambhir is an over rated player with faulty technique to open for India both
> in ODs and tests. Gambhir is a tiger against minnows bangladesh and
> zimbabwe.

> Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance against
> Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a perfect
foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and company  and
even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

I think Chopra deserves a chance with Ganguly not coming down on him
after every innings. If Jaffer plays fine, then good luck to him.

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by shariq_ta.. » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 03:35:10

Quote:

> Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance against
> Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

Well you will find that out in the next couple of months. That being
said do you think that Shoaib Malik has a chance to succeed against the
Indian new ball bowlers?

Shariq

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Sanja » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 03:31:44


Quote:


>> Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance
>> against
>> Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

> Well you will find that out in the next couple of months. That being
> said do you think that Shoaib Malik has a chance to succeed against the
> Indian new ball bowlers?

> Shariq

Shoaib Malik did well against India in ODs with an average of 44.53 even
though his overall career average is only 33.0

I believe Shoaib Malik can translate his OD performances into tests and
score well against India.

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Spaceman Spif » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 03:55:39

[snip]
Quote:

> That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
> but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a perfect
> foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and company  and
> even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

[snip]

why is it so hard for him to score runs then?

--
stay cool,
Spaceman Spiff

get your own damn grateful dead lyrics.
http://arts.ucsc.edu/gdead/agdl/

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by ampar.. » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 04:24:35

Quote:


> [snip]

> > That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
> > but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a perfect
> > foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and company  and
> > even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

> [snip]

> why is it so hard for him to score runs then?

Just as it has been hard for Gambhir and every other opener in the last
years barring Sehwag. At least Gambhir whatever runs he scored, he did
it against top class opposition and was part of many a famous win for
India in recent times ( Adelaide, Multan )
Quote:

> --
> stay cool,
> Spaceman Spiff

> get your own damn grateful dead lyrics.
> http://arts.ucsc.edu/gdead/agdl/

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by VJ » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 04:33:34

Have you seen Akash's scores in the last year on the domestic circuit?
I would suggest also looking at his strike rate when facing these
demonical bowlers in the Ranji Trophy etc. He is not fit for test
cricket. Openers should have good technique but also a sense of purpose
to keep the score ticking. Just blocking does not get you anywhere.
 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Spaceman Spif » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 04:51:57

Quote:



>> [snip]

>>> That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
>>> but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a
>>> perfect foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and
>>> company  and even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

>> [snip]

>> why is it so hard for him to score runs then?

> Just as it has been hard for Gambhir and every other opener in the
> last years barring Sehwag.

it's been harder for chopra, by far.
he is not scoring runs even in domestic cricket for the last two years!
give me a break!

Quote:
> At least Gambhir whatever runs he scored,
> he did it against top class opposition and was part of many a famous
> win for India in recent times ( Adelaide, Multan )

you mean chopra, i presume. chopra barely scored runs against aussies and
pak. nothing to be proud of.
in test cricket, gambhir scored 96 vs rsa and batted decently in the series
vs pak in india (average 35.8).
i think rsa and pak are quality opposition.
he has sucked big time in the last 2 tests vs sl.
but he is getting more chances because of tina factor.

--
stay cool,
Spaceman Spiff

get your own damn grateful dead lyrics.
http://arts.ucsc.edu/gdead/agdl/

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by prasen » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 05:02:41

Quote:
> Just as it has been hard for Gambhir and every other opener in the last
> years barring Sehwag. At least Gambhir whatever runs he scored, he did
> it against top class opposition and was part of many a famous win for

like Zim, Bangla.

Quote:
> India in recent times ( Adelaide, Multan )

> > --
> > stay cool,
> > Spaceman Spiff

> > get your own damn grateful dead lyrics.
> > http://arts.ucsc.edu/gdead/agdl/

-pm
 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Nouman Ahma » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 05:23:50

Ah yes, Agarkar and 80 mph Pathan. I think Malik will do quite well...
 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by VJ » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 05:54:17

Quote:
> 80 mph Pathan. I think Malik will do quite well...

Words to archive. Its not just the pace but also the trajectory that is
important.
 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Sanja » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 05:58:25


Quote:



>>> [snip]

>>>> That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
>>>> but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a
>>>> perfect foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and
>>>> company  and even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

>>> [snip]

>>> why is it so hard for him to score runs then?

>> Just as it has been hard for Gambhir and every other opener in the
>> last years barring Sehwag.

> it's been harder for chopra, by far.
> he is not scoring runs even in domestic cricket for the last two years!
> give me a break!

>> At least Gambhir whatever runs he scored,
>> he did it against top class opposition and was part of many a famous
>> win for India in recent times ( Adelaide, Multan )

> you mean chopra, i presume. chopra barely scored runs against aussies and
> pak. nothing to be proud of.
> in test cricket, gambhir scored 96 vs rsa and batted decently in the
> series

Give me a break. The 96 was on a flat track where SA scored 510 and India
466 in a boring, dull drawn test.

Quote:
> vs pak in india (average 35.8).
> i think rsa and pak are quality opposition.
> --
> stay cool,
> Spaceman Spiff

> get your own damn grateful dead lyrics.
> http://arts.ucsc.edu/gdead/agdl/

And 35 average against  pak is no big deal. Even Kamran Akmal scored a
century in  Mohali where gambhir scored a 41 and another 32* not out in that
drawn test. Guess what bro, there are about twelve 50+ scores in that Mohali
test.

So far gambhir hasnt proved he has what it takes to succeed at the highest
level against quality opposition.

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Narayana » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 06:18:21

I didnot make any mistake in fuc*cking ur mom doggy style.  ha ha ha
she now luvs the "milkshake"

Quote:
> Gambhir is an over rated player with faulty technique to open for India
> both in ODs and tests. Gambhir is a tiger against minnows bangladesh and
> zimbabwe.

> Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance against
> Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by Mike Holman » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 07:26:41


Quote:


>> Selecting Jaffer is a good move but I wonder if he stands a chance against
>> Shoaib, Naved, Harmison, Jones and Flintoff.

>Well you will find that out in the next couple of months. That being
>said do you think that Shoaib Malik has a chance to succeed against the
>Indian new ball bowlers?

Other than various Zimbabweans, who doesn't?

Cheers,

Mike

 
 
 

Chappell made a mistake keeping Gambhir

Post by adipol » Fri, 16 Dec 2005 12:55:07

Quote:




>>>[snip]

>>>>That's why I seriously feel that Chopra might not be a great batsman
>>>>but he is adequate with a pretty decent technique and serves a
>>>>perfect foil to Sehwag. and of course, he has played Shoaib and
>>>>company  and even has toured Australia( which is a big test).

>>>[snip]

>>>why is it so hard for him to score runs then?

>>Just as it has been hard for Gambhir and every other opener in the
>>last years barring Sehwag.

> it's been harder for chopra, by far.
> he is not scoring runs even in domestic cricket for the last two years!
> give me a break!

>>At least Gambhir whatever runs he scored,
>>he did it against top class opposition and was part of many a famous
>>win for India in recent times ( Adelaide, Multan )

> you mean chopra, i presume. chopra barely scored runs against aussies and
> pak. nothing to be proud of.
> in test cricket, gambhir scored 96 vs rsa and batted decently in the series
> vs pak in india (average 35.8).
> i think rsa and pak are quality opposition.
> he has sucked big time in the last 2 tests vs sl.
> but he is getting more chances because of tina factor.

what is tina factor ?