Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 17:17:26


Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

17 players.....

Warner
Cowan
Watson
Clarke
Hughes
Marsh
Doolan
Faulkner
Wade
Haddin
Siddle
Starc
MJ
Harris
Hilf
Bird
Lyons

Christ, I hope I am so wrong. The hardest thing was picking players who
call themselves batsmen

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 17:21:45


Quote:
> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

> 17 players.....

> Warner
> Cowan
> Watson
> Clarke
> Hughes
> Marsh
> Doolan
> Faulkner
> Wade
> Haddin
> Siddle
> Starc
> MJ
> Harris
> Hilf
> Bird
> Lyons

> Christ, I hope I am so wrong. The hardest thing was picking players who
> call themselves batsmen

oops, forgot Pattinson who is a cert

so Pattinson in for Hilf

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by CaraMi » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 18:31:30


Quote:
> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

> 17 players.....

> Warner
> Cowan
> Watson
> Clarke
> Hughes
> Marsh
> Doolan
> Faulkner
> Wade
> Haddin
> Siddle
> Starc
> MJ
> Harris
> Hilf
> Bird
> Lyons

Why do you think Smith won't be picked? He was your best batsman after
Clarke in the India tour.

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 18:55:32


Quote:

>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>> 17 players.....

>> Warner
>> Cowan
>> Watson
>> Clarke
>> Hughes
>> Marsh
>> Doolan
>> Faulkner
>> Wade
>> Haddin
>> Siddle
>> Starc
>> MJ
>> Harris
>> Hilf
>> Bird
>> Lyons

> Why do you think Smith won't be picked? He was your best batsman after
> Clarke in the India tour.

  good against spin but against swinging ball he may struggle
 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Maxx » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 19:17:06


Quote:


> >> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
> >> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

> >> 17 players.....

> >> Warner
> >> Cowan
> >> Watson
> >> Clarke
> >> Hughes
> >> Marsh
> >> Doolan
> >> Faulkner
> >> Wade
> >> Haddin
> >> Siddle
> >> Starc
> >> MJ
> >> Harris
> >> Hilf
> >> Bird
> >> Lyons

> > Why do you think Smith won't be picked? He was your best batsman after
> > Clarke in the India tour.

> ? good against spin but against swinging ball he may struggle-

You're breaking your own rules.
 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by CaraMi » Thu, 04 Apr 2013 19:45:22


Quote:

>> Why do you think Smith won't be picked? He was your best batsman after
>> Clarke in the India tour.

>   good against spin but against swinging ball he may struggle

How do you know? Did you think he would be good against spin before the
India tour?
 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Sir Leslie Bottock » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 05:28:23


Quote:

>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>> 17 players.....

>> Warner
>> Cowan
>> Watson
>> Clarke
>> Hughes
>> Marsh
>> Doolan
>> Faulkner
>> Wade
>> Haddin
>> Siddle
>> Starc
>> MJ
>> Harris
>> Hilf
>> Bird
>> Lyons

>> Christ, I hope I am so wrong. The hardest thing was picking players who
>> call themselves batsmen

> oops, forgot Pattinson who is a cert

> so Pattinson in for Hilf

Doohan. Marsh???

they'll not be there, Will. You've been listening to Rob's nonsense, no
doubt?

Hilf is contracted, so I suspect he will be there. So

Smith for Doohan
Kawhaja for Marsh
Pattinson for Faukner/Harris

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Geoff Muldoo » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 08:58:26


Quote:

> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

> 17 players.....

> Warner
> Cowan
> Watson
> Clarke
> Hughes
> Marsh
> Doolan

Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?

Quote:
> Faulkner

Maybe Henriques or Maxwell instead?

Quote:
> Wade
> Haddin
> Siddle
> Starc
> MJ
> Harris
> Hilf
> Bird

Don't think they'll take that many quicks, and Pattinson will be in the
group of what I think will probably only be 5, so two of
Bird/Harris/Hilf/MJ to miss out?

Quote:
> Lyons

Add another spinner, unless Maxwell is included above as the all-rounder
(in which case they will take the sixth quick), so Maxwell or maybe even
O'Keefe?

GM

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Mike Holman » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 09:22:26

On Thu, 4 Apr 2013 10:58:26 +1100, Geoff Muldoon

Quote:

>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>> 17 players.....

>> Warner
>> Cowan
>> Watson
>> Clarke
>> Hughes
>> Marsh
>> Doolan
>Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?

Over the next 12 months, Australia will be playing against England a
lot. You'd think that CA wouldn't bother centrally contracting people
if they didn't intend to pick them for the Ashes, and why wouldn't
they contract those they are expecting to pick?

Cheers,

Mike
--

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by jzfredrick » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 10:03:16

Quote:

> >Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?
> Over the next 12 months, Australia will be playing against England a
> lot. You'd think that CA wouldn't bother centrally contracting people
> if they didn't intend to pick them for the Ashes, and why wouldn't
> they contract those they are expecting to pick?

It could be a stupid attempt at mind games - a surprise call-up at the last minute to catch England unprepared.

In a year's time I'd like to come back to this post and compare this list with those who end up playing for Aus in the coming 12 months. I suspect there will be some big changes.

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 11:25:57


Quote:

>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>> 17 players.....

>> Warner
>> Cowan
>> Watson
>> Clarke
>> Hughes
>> Marsh
>> Doolan
> Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?

heard Invers saying that he considered Smith good for India due to spion
but not suited for England

Quote:

>> Faulkner
> Maybe Henriques or Maxwell instead?

Faulkner looked good in the SS final and has a CA contract. As for
Maxwell, jeez........are we that desperate ?

Quote:

>> Wade
>> Haddin

>> Siddle
>> Starc
>> MJ
>> Harris
>> Hilf
>> Bird
> Don't think they'll take that many quicks, and Pattinson will be in the
> group of what I think will probably only be 5, so two of
> Bird/Harris/Hilf/MJ to miss out?

yes, picked up Patto just after I posted and corrected

Quote:

>> Lyons
> Add another spinner, unless Maxwell is included above as the all-rounder
> (in which case they will take the sixth quick), so Maxwell or maybe even
> O'Keefe?

> GM

the selectors took a lot of pace bowlers to India and only 2 spinners so
I guess on that theory they will take 5 spinners to England  :-)
also O'Keefe is out of favour with the selectors

So now Geoff name the squad you think the selectors will pick

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 11:27:26


Quote:
> On Thu, 4 Apr 2013 10:58:26 +1100, Geoff Muldoon


>>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>>> 17 players.....

>>> Warner
>>> Cowan
>>> Watson
>>> Clarke
>>> Hughes
>>> Marsh
>>> Doolan
>> Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?

> Over the next 12 months, Australia will be playing against England a
> lot. You'd think that CA wouldn't bother centrally contracting people
> if they didn't intend to pick them for the Ashes, and why wouldn't
> they contract those they are expecting to pick?

I wouild say at least 6 of that squad were contracted due to 20/20 and
ODI's commitments
 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by willsutto » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 11:33:03


Quote:



>>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>>> 17 players.....

>>> Warner
>>> Cowan
>>> Watson
>>> Clarke
>>> Hughes
>>> Marsh
>>> Doolan
>>> Faulkner
>>> Wade
>>> Haddin
>>> Siddle
>>> Starc
>>> MJ
>>> Harris
>>> Hilf
>>> Bird
>>> Lyons

>>> Christ, I hope I am so wrong. The hardest thing was picking players who
>>> call themselves batsmen

>> oops, forgot Pattinson who is a cert

>> so Pattinson in for Hilf

> Doohan. Marsh???

> they'll not be there, Will. You've been listening to Rob's nonsense, no
> doubt?

I think the selectors will pick them there for one reason... the
cupboard is bare and I mean ***ING bare

Quote:

> Hilf is contracted, so I suspect he will be there. So

Faulkner and Harris are also contracted

Quote:

> Smith for Doohan
> Kawhaja for Marsh
> Pattinson for Faukner/Harris

Kawhaja is on the nose after not doing his homework and didnt even get a
Test in India when we were desperate. Smith cant get a contract and when
the Chairman of selectors say they picked him basically for India only I
cant see him getting picked.
 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Geoff Muldoo » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 12:29:51


Quote:
> So now Geoff name the squad you think the selectors will pick

Clarke (c)
Watson (vc)
Warner
Cowan
Hughes
Marsh
Henriques
Maxwell
Wade
Haddin
Siddle
Starc
Johnson
Hilfenhaus
Pattinson
Harris
Lyon

Yes, because of the dire state of our batting stocks I think that they
will take both Henriques and Maxwell to try and add a bit of depth to
the batting lineup.  Marsh will be given his final chance because
Khawaja's been sent to the *** chair.  Haddin will be given a
swansong tour before Paine comes in.  O'Keefe should get one of the
seamer spots but is out of favour.  Harris will get used until he breaks
down, then Bird will be a late call-up even though he should have had
Hilf's spot inn the first place.

GM

 
 
 

Contest : Name the Oz Ashes Squad

Post by Sir Leslie Bottock » Fri, 05 Apr 2013 16:08:52


Quote:

>> Name the Ashes squad that you think the selectors will pick NOT the
>> players who you would pick. Put you comments in for a good laugh

>> 17 players.....

>> Warner
>> Cowan
>> Watson
>> Clarke
>> Hughes
>> Marsh
>> Doolan
> Maybe Smith instead of Doolan?

>> Faulkner
> Maybe Henriques or Maxwell instead?

>> Wade
>> Haddin

>> Siddle
>> Starc
>> MJ
>> Harris
>> Hilf
>> Bird
> Don't think they'll take that many quicks, and Pattinson will be in the
> group of what I think will probably only be 5, so two of
> Bird/Harris/Hilf/MJ to miss out?

>> Lyons
> Add another spinner, unless Maxwell is included above as the all-rounder
> (in which case they will take the sixth quick), so Maxwell or maybe even
> O'Keefe?

medium/quick bowling is Oz's strength (relatively speaking). I'd say take 6,
and only 1 spinner. They're never going to play more than 1 spinner at a
time, and if Lyon does get injured close to game day they can just play an
all pace attack.