Bad Captaincy

Bad Captaincy

Post by Will_ » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 08:38:15


IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from one
end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.
 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by Paji » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 08:50:21

Quote:

> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from one
> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

Does it really matter? anyone can get the 3 remaning guys out - but
spinners
are likely to do the job at the earliest.

 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by Will_ » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 09:29:13


Quote:


>> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from
>> one
>> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

> Does it really matter? anyone can get the 3 remaning guys out - but
> spinners
> are likely to do the job at the earliest.

You nether take anything for granted ie. Hussey & McGrath

And I reckon the quick / spinner combination would have been more effective
1st up

 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by RodP » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 10:12:45


01.iinet.net.au>,
Will_S says...

Quote:
> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from one
> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

It's bad captaincy because in your opinion Ponting has got it wrong?

--
Cheers,
Rod.

 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by Abhiji » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 10:35:20

Quote:


> 01.iinet.net.au>,
> Will_S says...

> > IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from one
> > end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

> It's bad captaincy because in your opinion Ponting has got it wrong?

No, in his opinion it's bad captaincy because in his opinion Ponting
has got it wrong.
[I always think IMHO is there by default]
 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by Will_ » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 10:43:09


Quote:

> 01.iinet.net.au>,
> Will_S says...

>> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from
>> one
>> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

> It's bad captaincy because in your opinion Ponting has got it wrong?

> --
> Cheers,
> Rod.

Well thats what I said Rod or dont you know what IMHO means ?

You have a shock weapon in Lee so let him fly at them for 4 or 5 overs
before they get settled.

 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by RodP » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 10:55:50


01.iinet.net.au>,
Will_S says...

Quote:




> > 01.iinet.net.au>,
> > Will_S says...

> >> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from
> >> one
> >> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

> > It's bad captaincy because in your opinion Ponting has got it wrong?

> > --
> > Cheers,
> > Rod.

> Well thats what I said Rod or dont you know what IMHO means ?

> You have a shock weapon in Lee so let him fly at them for 4 or 5 overs
> before they get settled.

Look at the title of the thread, Will.

--
Cheers,
Rod.

 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by bringbackthafoot » Sat, 31 Dec 2005 19:22:28

Quote:

> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from one
> end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

I guess the selectors will be looking to promote you to
captain in the next test.
 
 
 

Bad Captaincy

Post by Somefell » Mon, 02 Jan 2006 17:33:08


Quote:
> IMHO I think Ponting has once again got it wrong. I would have spin from
> one end and 4 over spells from Lee , McGrath & Symonds at the other end.

He's a bad captain because he didn't do what you think? Maybe you should be
captain?