Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by guptatr.. » Thu, 04 May 2006 07:04:47


Who is a better batsman? opener? ODI versus test? fielder? any one
bowls?

from what I have seen, it seems Dhawan has scored more runs and at a
faster pace than Uthappa, still Uthappah got the break?

does Dhawan has any chances of a break soon?  I think he should replace
Jaffer........

Rakesh

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by Jaide » Thu, 04 May 2006 07:10:00


Quote:

> Who is a better batsman? opener? ODI versus test? fielder? any one
> bowls?

> from what I have seen, it seems Dhawan has scored more runs and at a
> faster pace than Uthappa, still Uthappah got the break?

> does Dhawan has any chances of a break soon?  I think he should replace
> Jaffer........

> Rakesh

Uthappa performance in the Challengers got him in ahead of Dhawan.

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by RSquar » Thu, 04 May 2006 15:33:51

But at AbuDhabi Dhawan played a lot better than Utthappa. May be that
opposit teams were not good enough but was same for Utthappa.

Rakesh R

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by guptatr.. » Fri, 05 May 2006 23:46:31

or was it Dravid connection?

rg

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by Jaide » Sat, 06 May 2006 01:04:06


Quote:
> or was it Dravid connection?

> rg

            R   B   4   6
AR Uthappa            c Jadhav           b VR Singh           116  93  19  2
S Dhawan              run out (Tiwary)                             40  47
5  0

Did Dravid stop Dhawan from scoring a 116 of 93 balls with 19 fours and 2
sixes in the Challengers ?

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by guptatr.. » Sat, 06 May 2006 02:33:28

You can not elect a person based on one outing.  Since then and even
before that dhawan has been more consistent than Uthappa.............

Uthappa's Stat:
ODIs   2   2   0   98   86   49.00   120   81.66   0   1   13   1   1
0
First-class   20   32   0   1037   162   32.40   1777   58.35   1   6
      24   0
List A   28   28   1   1117   160   41.37   1243   89.86   3   7
 9   0

Dhawan:
First-class   15   26   1   1037   130   41.47   2208   46.96   2   6
16   0
List A   24   24   4   1123   131*   56.14   1406   79.87   4   5   7
0

U's averages are 32.4 and 41.4
D's averages are 41.5 and 56.1

I think Dhawan is a better player.  He is also a leftie and right-left
combination is good at the top of the order.............

rakesh

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by Jaide » Sat, 06 May 2006 09:59:27


Quote:

> You can not elect a person based on one outing.  Since then and even
> before that dhawan has been more consistent than Uthappa.............

> Uthappa's Stat:
> ODIs   2   2   0   98   86   49.00   120   81.66   0   1   13   1   1
> 0
> First-class   20   32   0   1037   162   32.40   1777   58.35   1   6
>      24   0
> List A   28   28   1   1117   160   41.37   1243   89.86   3   7
> 9   0

> Dhawan:
> First-class   15   26   1   1037   130   41.47   2208   46.96   2   6
> 16   0
> List A   24   24   4   1123   131*   56.14   1406   79.87   4   5   7
> 0

> U's averages are 32.4 and 41.4
> D's averages are 41.5 and 56.1

> I think Dhawan is a better player.  He is also a leftie and right-left
> combination is good at the top of the order.............

> rakesh

I never said Uthappa is a better player than Dhawan. I merely said Uthappa
impressed Chappell and the selectors in challengers and got selected.

Dravid is not like ganguly to pull his statemates or southern mates into the
team like ganguly did with northies.

If Dravid had any real power and bias he would have succeeded in persuading
Chappell to include his buddy Kumble in the OD team.

Dravid stood behind the mediocre and useless kaif despite less than 10
average in the last 10 ODs is proof enough he doesnt have any regional
considerations and biases.

And he replaced SreeSanth with RP Singh and Munaf in the ODs when the
situation warranted also proves he is above regional biases.

 
 
 

Uthappa versus S. Dhawan

Post by prasen » Sun, 07 May 2006 06:16:14

Quote:



> > You can not elect a person based on one outing.  Since then and even
> > before that dhawan has been more consistent than Uthappa.............

> > Uthappa's Stat:
> > ODIs   2   2   0   98   86   49.00   120   81.66   0   1   13   1   1
> > 0
> > First-class   20   32   0   1037   162   32.40   1777   58.35   1   6
> >      24   0
> > List A   28   28   1   1117   160   41.37   1243   89.86   3   7
> > 9   0

> > Dhawan:
> > First-class   15   26   1   1037   130   41.47   2208   46.96   2   6
> > 16   0
> > List A   24   24   4   1123   131*   56.14   1406   79.87   4   5   7
> > 0

> > U's averages are 32.4 and 41.4
> > D's averages are 41.5 and 56.1

> > I think Dhawan is a better player.  He is also a leftie and right-left
> > combination is good at the top of the order.............

> > rakesh

> I never said Uthappa is a better player than Dhawan. I merely said Uthappa
> impressed Chappell and the selectors in challengers and got selected.

> Dravid is not like ganguly to pull his statemates or southern mates into the
> team like ganguly did with northies.

Ahem yes, Ganguly played for the North Zone.  Anything else?

Quote:

> If Dravid had any real power and bias he would have succeeded in persuading
> Chappell to include his buddy Kumble in the OD team.

> Dravid stood behind the mediocre and useless kaif despite less than 10
> average in the last 10 ODs is proof enough he doesnt have any regional
> considerations and biases.

> And he replaced SreeSanth with RP Singh and Munaf in the ODs when the
> situation warranted also proves he is above regional biases.

And Ganguly passionately wanted Srinath not to retire because like
Ganguly,
Srinath was from the North Pole, sorry Zone.  Ganguly's support of
Balaji
also proves that both were from the North Pole, sorry Mars.  Everything
is
crystal clear and so easy to prove.

-pm