Ron ripped off

Ron ripped off

Post by Victo » Wed, 23 Jul 1997 04:00:00


Did Ron De Iulio really deserve four weeks for that?  It's a given in that
situation that Bewick goes into overacting overdrive - the contact seemed
fairly slight on the replay.

Personally I'd mint a medal for anyone who does Bewick significant harm.

Victor

 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by The cogger » Wed, 23 Jul 1997 04:00:00

Oh 2 knees isn't enough for him

Quote:

> Did Ron De Iulio really deserve four weeks for that?  It's a given in
> that
> situation that Bewick goes into overacting overdrive - the contact
> seemed
> fairly slight on the replay.

> Personally I'd mint a medal for anyone who does Bewick significant
> harm.

> Victor


 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by Shau » Wed, 23 Jul 1997 04:00:00

Quote:

>Did Ron De Iulio really deserve four weeks for that?  

Hey! I'm a Carlton supporter but i think this one was fair enough.

It's a given in that

Quote:
>situation that Bewick goes into overacting overdrive - the contact seemed
>fairly slight on the replay.

No way! Bewick was clearly in pain
I reckon you're being a bit biased there Victor :-)

Quote:
>Personally I'd mint a medal for anyone who does Bewick significant harm.

Mongrel :-)
I don't mind Bewick at all. Loved his come back game against Geelong last
year when he begged 9 goals and showed Che***atoo-Collins how to play
around forwad line
Quote:
>Victor


 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by Herb » Wed, 23 Jul 1997 04:00:00


Quote:

>Did Ron De Iulio really deserve four weeks for that?  It's a given in that
>situation that Bewick goes into overacting overdrive - the contact seemed
>fairly slight on the replay.

Slight enough for Bewick to hobble around for the next five minutes.  De
Iulio should have been booked for an attempted trip, so that Bewick could
have got 50m.  Not that it would have changed the result.

Quote:

>Personally I'd mint a medal for anyone who does Bewick significant harm.

>Victor

I hope you're joking.

Herbie

"They put a hotwire to my head 'cause of the things I did and said and made these feelings go away, model citizen in every way." - J Lydon

 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by Victo » Thu, 24 Jul 1997 04:00:00

Quote:
> >Did Ron De Iulio really deserve four weeks for that?  It's a given in
that
> >situation that Bewick goes into overacting overdrive - the contact
seemed
> >fairly slight on the replay.

> Slight enough for Bewick to hobble around for the next five minutes.  De
> Iulio should have been booked for an attempted trip, so that Bewick could
> have got 50m.  Not that it would have changed the result.

Bewick hobbles, grimaces, moans and groans as he's running out for the
start of the game.

I only saw the incident once, De Iulio was falling over and backwards, it
looked about as vicious as Daniel Day-Lewis, in "My Left Foot," saying
gidday to his mum.

That said, there is an extra aura of evil around misdemeanors of the boot,
and relative to other penalties it wasn't extraordinary.  But the image of
the incident still jars with the magnitude of the penalty.

What would you prefer: Ron's "kick" or the equivalent four weeks worth of
raised elbow?

Quote:

> >Personally I'd mint a medal for anyone who does Bewick significant harm.

> I hope you're joking.

No.

Victor

 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by John Ch » Fri, 25 Jul 1997 04:00:00



Quote:
>What would you prefer: Ron's "kick" or the equivalent four weeks worth of
>raised elbow?

Well if I have a***y knee (as does Bewick with 2 reconstructions
already), I'd take the elbow. I think the sentence had a lot to do
with the fact that it *was* Bewick's bad knee and had a high chance of
seriously injurying him.

John!
.,-~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,.
ATTENTION: To reply via e-mail, remove the X's
from the start of my e-mail address!

John Chua

ATTENTION: To reply via e-mail, remove the X's
from the start of my e-mail address!
.,-~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,._.,-*~'`^`'~*-,.

 
 
 

Ron ripped off

Post by David J Richards » Fri, 25 Jul 1997 04:00:00



[Don't you like replying to your own messages?]

Quote:
>CCC has been utter shit this year - geez, I'd nearly name Mark Fraser
>instead of him.

>(Just joking.)

I WAS JUST JOKING!!!

Sheez.

Get Moorcroft back in - talk about contrasts of hard and soft players...

--
David J Richardson

SOPHIE ALDRED (ACE IN DR WHO) MELBOURNE NOV 21-23 - ASK ME ABOUT IT!