Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by Yvonne Wen-Yi W » Tue, 10 Oct 2000 04:00:00


Is this a good deal? Culpepper and Robert Smith for Jimmy Smith?
Its a Sandbox league with pts on TDs, yards...
I have plenty of depth with Garcia, Brunell, Ricky Williams,
E.James, Q.Ismail, Moss, J.Horn, Warrick, and K.Faulk... but
I feel I could use another stud WR...

thanks...

--
       ______________/------------------------------------\______________

          \_______/------------------------------------------\_______/
             \___    University of Maryland at College Park    ___/
                \________/----------------------------\________/

 
 
 

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by Vickohg » Tue, 10 Oct 2000 04:00:00

That is a terrible trade for you. Jimmy Smith is a decent (but not a
marque)player, but no way is he worth both of those players. Look for a better
trade elsewhere, this guy is trying to rip you off.

Vic

 
 
 

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by Juman » Tue, 10 Oct 2000 04:00:00



Quote:
>Is this a good deal? Culpepper and Robert Smith for Jimmy Smith?
>Its a Sandbox league with pts on TDs, yards...
>I have plenty of depth with Garcia, Brunell, Ricky Williams,
>E.James, Q.Ismail, Moss, J.Horn, Warrick, and K.Faulk... but
>I feel I could use another stud WR...

>thanks...

I wouldn't!  The offensive line in JAX is becoming "offensive"
Brunell is getting much time.  If you look at Taylor's Sunday night
stats, he got most of that during "garbage" time.

BAL was in the "prevent" defense and Taylor "looked" good.  Keep
Culpepper.  I would try and trade Brunell.....  Someone will think JAX
will get it together.

 
 
 

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by Jean Gogue » Tue, 10 Oct 2000 04:00:00

I'd wait and see how the QB situation in Jacksonville pans out.  If, for
whatever reason, Jamie Martin (is that his name?) ends up starting over
Brunell, there's a good chance that the #3/4 WR's are gonna start having
big fantasy games, because he's not used to throwing to Smith and
McCardell.
Quote:

> Is this a good deal? Culpepper and Robert Smith for Jimmy Smith?
> Its a Sandbox league with pts on TDs, yards...
> I have plenty of depth with Garcia, Brunell, Ricky Williams,
> E.James, Q.Ismail, Moss, J.Horn, Warrick, and K.Faulk... but
> I feel I could use another stud WR...

> thanks...

> --
>        ______________/------------------------------------\______________

>           \_______/------------------------------------------\_______/
>              \___    University of Maryland at College Park    ___/
>                 \________/----------------------------\________/

 
 
 

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by KJ » Tue, 10 Oct 2000 04:00:00

Quote:

> Is this a good deal? Culpepper and Robert Smith for Jimmy Smith?

No.
 
 
 

Trade Culpepper & R.Smith for J.Smith?

Post by Cla » Wed, 11 Oct 2000 11:25:57

Quote:

>That is a terrible trade for you. Jimmy Smith is a decent (but not a
>marque)player, but no way is he worth both of those players. Look for a better
>trade elsewhere, this guy is trying to rip you off.

I wouldn't make the trade either, but Smith IS a marquee player.
At least he was before Jax turned into Cleveland.

Clay