Speed vs. Height

Speed vs. Height

Post by Bill Dav » Tue, 02 Aug 1994 22:45:48


About ten years ago, a survey was conducted among college coaches asking
them to describe the ectomorphs of the "perfect" sprinter and the "perfect"
distance swimmer.  The result surprised some: The coaches wanted a tall (6'-
4" or taller), thin (180-200 lbs), with large hands and feet.  The
collective wisdom was that a tall athlete, all other things being equal,
will be cover a given distance (short or long) faster than a shorter one.

The prejudice in favor of taller players also extends to water polo.  I
think it was Ed Newland who wrote an article a couple of years ago
describing what he was looking for in a national team player.  Ed wanted
speed (21 seconds in the 50 or faster, but not "drop dead" speed-- they had
to have some endurance), strength, and-- surprise!-- size (6'4" or taller).  
Newland also described some non-physical attributes, but I think he was
pretty insistent that if you didn't have the strength, size, and speed, you
weren't going to be in the pool.

Marv Harshman (sp?), the former basketball coach at the University of
Washington, was once asked why he recruited tall, strong players rather than
short, quick players.  "Quick guys get tired," he responded.  "Big guys
don't shrink."

Now, my question is: when there is so much evidence of outstanding "smaller"
athletes, why do coaches instinctively or reflexively favor athletes who are
6'4" and taller?

BD

Height: 6'6"
Weight: 210-215 (depending on the day)
Significant Athletic Accomplishments: None

 
 
 

Speed vs. Height

Post by David Swarbri » Thu, 04 Aug 1994 02:31:15

Quote:

>About ten years ago, a survey was conducted among college coaches asking
>them to describe the ectomorphs of the "perfect" sprinter and the "perfect"
>distance swimmer.  The result surprised some: The coaches wanted a tall (6'-
>4" or taller), thin (180-200 lbs), with large hands and feet.  The
>collective wisdom was that a tall athlete, all other things being equal,
>will be cover a given distance (short or long) faster than a shorter one.

I think the average height of the finalists in the last Olympics 100m
mens freestyle final was 6ft5in.

Being much shorter  myself, it becomes opbvious - they turn a clear
foot further from the wall than I do, and their paddles are bigger

David
--
David Swarbrick                   | Just Mooting UK Law On-line
Swarbrick & Co, Solicitors        | +44 (0)484 401139 (24 hrs <=v.32bis)
22 Bradford Road Brighouse HD6 1RW|